you're reading...
current events, Religion

Lutherans Agree to Disagree about Homosexuals. Is This Progress?

The National Meeting for the Evangelical Lutheran Church of America (ECLA) has just voted by exactly a 2/3 majority to allow theological differences regarding sexuality and scripture.  The cynical part of me wants to say something snide.  The more thoughtful side of me is wondering if this is progress or not.

Sure, it’s “progress” for gays to have a church they can go to where they will be officially recognized as not having magical stains on their genitals.  It’s better to be accepted as gay than reviled and spat upon.  It’s also nice that there are now three Christian denominations in the U.S. that are moving towards the position that we rationalists have held for years — that homosexuality is normal and acceptable, and occurs all over the natural kingdom.  (The other two are Episcopals and United Church of Christ.)  That’s not to say that these groups have adopted the scientific position, but they’re moving towards it.

I’m not sure I think it’s all that great, though.  I have not read the minutes of this meeting, nor have I read anything explaining the rationale behind the decision to be a little less hateful and divisive.  Did they decide that the scientific evidence was overwhelmingly on the side of homosexuality as normal?  I suspect not.  I imagine this was more of a public opinion poll than a scientific inquiry.  Lutherans are typically a little more educated and liberal than Baptists, Methodists and Catholics.   I can imagine that the 66.7% who voted for this amendment all feel in their guts that it’s wrong to discriminate against gays.   It just feels wrong to be hateful towards good people who just happen to prefer rubbing bodies with members of the same sex.

The thing is, there’s nothing else to hang your hat on if there’s no real measure of truth.  This particular group of religious nutters has taken a step towards creating their religion in their own somewhat socially updated image.  They are finding ways to make the dogma match what they want to believe.   American society has become more tolerant of gays since the 50s, and a couple of churches are starting to catch up.  Specifically, the reason I doubt that this is real progress is in the detail that disagreements regarding scripture and sexuality are now allowable.  In other words, scripture — not evidence — is still the ultimate judge, but it’s possible that men screw up the interpretation, so they’ll allow disagreement.

May I humbly suggest that real progress would be a resolution that when scripture disagrees with overwhelming empirical evidence, the scripture is wrong?  How about a resolution to study all the evidence regarding homosexuality and then adjust the holy documents accordingly?  How about a resolution that any dogma that disagrees with science should be stricken from the holy documents?

Of course, that’s asking too much.  If they did that, they wouldn’t be a religion anymore, would they?  They’d be a group of folks getting together for pot luck on Wednesday and Sunday.  They’d be rationalists just like the rest of us.

Advertisements

Discussion

One thought on “Lutherans Agree to Disagree about Homosexuals. Is This Progress?

  1. it would be nice if all the bible reading churches would actually read the damn book instead of fondling it and using it as a fetish. Sure it is progress if it is no longer used as a weapon. We American Atheists do actually read the King James Bible. Clearly competent readers and translators can ascertain that Saul alias “Paul” was writing to Greek settlement & Roman settlement “churches” 1900 or less years ago to condemn “temple prostitution” which included the sale of young children for raping by the “customers” of the temples. Adult consentual relationships were not the targets of New Testament writers invectives. As for Old Testament writers, Jews were obsessed with patriarchy, male offspring, circumcision, female unclean-ness and “the law of jealousy in Numbers Chapter Six an insane rite of “proof” an accused woman was “innocent” if her “thy doth not rot” after literally drinking piss mixed with dirt from the “temple” floor.
    To this day many fundamentalist Jews pray first in the morning: “thank adonai I am not a woman.” It is no wonder that the only way to raise large numbers of Hebrew warriours is to breed many females and curse female births.
    ONAN was punished not for masturbation but for the crime of not impregnating his sister in law upon the death of his brother. SPILLING HIS SEED ON THE GROUND is equal to anal inter course in the context of this disgusying triple orbits of Abrahamic religions.
    Consistently reading Aramaic, Arabic and Hebrew texts in history yields a brutal pattern all loyal to these faiths deny is there, unless when conveniently cited for some stoning, beheading or suicide bombing.
    I wonder how many gays would really be gay if not raped as children by incest or priests, circumcized as infants in senseless non-medical rituals & never medical even for phimosis, when only a urine bubble need be pierced.
    For the never brutalized adult consentual gays & lesbians, “progress” from 3 religions is not all that valuable.
    No church yet has condemned as “wrong” calling Atheists “fools” and “reprobates.” Until then, loyalty to Lutherans Episcopals & C of C is more out of fear to stick with the fiction of Jehovah & Jeebus & proof ghost holes are still in their heads. Atheism remains the solution to reading, exposing cultural error to scrutiny and not letting haunting sermons or “morals” ruin natural loving life.

    Posted by Larry Carter Center | August 24, 2009, 12:19 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow Me On Twitter!

%d bloggers like this: