you're reading...
Culture, morality, Politics, Religion

Open Letter to Moderates and Agnostics

If you are still riding the fence about whether non-believers are moral people, here’s a little tidbit from the Pew Research Center.  White Evangelical Protestants agree at a startling 62% that torture can sometimes or often be justified.  One out of five thinks we ought to use it often.  Significantly less “unaffiliated” (psst… non-believers) agree — forty percent.

There is, of course, the question of chickens and eggs.  Do torture supporters go to church, or do churchgoers support torture?  Pew implies that it is something of a circular relationship:  “[P]arty and ideology are much better predictors of views on torture than are religion and most other demographic factors… Of course, religion itself is known to be a strong factor shaping individuals’ partisanship and political ideology.”

In one very important sense, it’s not really that important what’s causing what.  The fact is — THE FACT IS — that non-religious people are less in favor of torture than religious people.  Once again, we are the most moral people when a single issue is quantified.  It’s also worth noting that for Pew, “unaffiliated” includes atheists, agnostics, “spiritual but not religious,” and many other categories.  I suspect that if we broke out “open atheists,” we would find an ever starker contrast.

On April 29, Gregory Paul and Phil Zuckerman published an article in the Washington Post calling attention to the tacit support for discrimination against atheists.  “Rarely denounced by the mainstream, this stunning anti-atheist discrimination is egged on by Christian conservatives who stridently — and uncivilly — declare that the lack of godly faith is detrimental to society, rendering nonbelievers intrinsically suspect and second-class citizens.”  The most disturbing aspect of this bigotry is that the mainstream doesn’t oppose it.  The evidence is out there, and it’s clear:

  • Torture
  • Death Penalty
  • Hitting Children
  • Racism
  • Sexism
  • Divorce
  • Homophobia
  • Anti-semitism
  • Anti-environmentalism
  • Anti-Human Rights
  • Unsafe sex
  • Jail Population
  • Murder

These are the special milieus of the religious.  In each one of these categories of moral behavior and attitudes, non-believers demonstrate better morality than believers.  And yet, the great un-committed middle — the nominal believers, the liberal denominations, the New Agers, the polite agnostics — allow and even condone open discrimination and silencing of atheists.

Once again, I must stress that it doesn’t really matter which is the chicken and which is the egg.  It’s an important question that I’d like to see answered in my lifetime, but it’s not relevant to the question of continued discrimination against non-believers.  Regardless of the cause, we are more moral than believers.

Anything less than public denunciation of discrimination is equivalent to condoning it.  Time and again, the Far Right Theocrats prove to be the least moral people in America, and yet atheists are singled out for censure.  We are the ones receiving hate mail for our billboards — despite the fact that church billboards outnumber ours at least a thousand to one.

You can choose a ready guide in some celestial voice
If you choose not to decide, you still have made a choice — RUSH

We open atheists would like to see agnostics and nominal believers — those for whom religious dogma does not inform day-to-day life, but who acknowledge belief in a higher power — put an end to this.  We don’t ask that you give up your belief in god, or your suspicion that there might be purpose to it all.  We simply ask that you acknowledge and act upon the facts:  Non-believers are not immoral people.  We are in fact more moral than those who condemn us.

This is no longer a matter of personal opinion.  Those who hold the belief that atheists are immoral are wrong.  We do not lead society into anarchy.  We don’t lead children into early sex, pregnancy, and disease.  We aren’t communists.  We don’t have a “homosexual agenda” and we aren’t bent on turning your child into a fagalicious queen.  (But we’ll accept him and love him if he does turn out to be gay.  Will our accusers do the same?)

The blatant discrimination against atheists is based on a lie.  A gigantic lie.  An unconscionable lie.  A lie that is disturbingly similar to the one that led millions to gas chambers the last time a Christian managed to foment the collective bigotry of a nation in economic distress.

The fact is, we atheists are everywhere.  We’re your neighbors, your employees, your friends, your babysitters.  We have been living next to you for your whole life, and we’ve never done anything to you.  Even so, there is a loud and angry voice from the far right — the far right trying to sell you a discriminatory Constitutional amendment, the end of women’s rights, union busting, and the collapse of medicare — insisting that we are the enemy.

WAKE UP!  It’s not us.  If you truly believe in the Bible, I suggest you heed its advice:  Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?  Look at what we’re doing, and what they’re doing.  Decide for yourself.  Please stop maintaining polite silence while twenty percent of us are being labeled as angry, immoral, and anti-American by those who are brazenly flaunting their own anger and immorality, and openly legislating the end of “liberty for all.”



3 thoughts on “Open Letter to Moderates and Agnostics

  1. I think all they have to do is look around. This is why letting people know you’re an atheist is important. The more moral atheists in public the better. The less immoral atheists in public the better.

    I also think it`s important to seperate people who don`t actually condone or allow discrimination and silence of atheists, and those that do.

    I have been thrown the accusation of the latter.

    Posted by cptpineapple | May 4, 2011, 2:34 pm
  2. Well, yeah… if someone is a moderate or agnostic who’s openly speaking out against discrimination, I’m not talking to them. The problem I’m running into is that I’m meeting precious few of them, and the polls indicate that they’re the most populous subgroup in America. (That is, non-fundamentalist theists and agnostic/undecideds combined.)

    (40%-ish of Americans are evangelicals/fundamentalists/non-evolutionists, etc… 15% (ish) are atheists. That leaves 45% in the middle.)

    Posted by Living Life Without a Net | May 4, 2011, 2:50 pm
  3. What I hate of religion is the importance of chosing a team: the “good” people or the “bad” people. What I hate of many atheists is exactly the same. You guys can become so fanatic and stupid as the people you point to. The problem is not religious or atheist people: the problem is people. We all are the same bunch of filth, no matter our beliefs. I know believers who murder, claim for death penalty, torture, defend homophobia, racism, sexism… etc. AND I KNOW ATHEISTS AND AGNOSTICS WHO DO EXACLTY THE SAME. So cut the crap: don’t tell me I’m good and superior for not believing in God, and an evil troglodite if I do. I’m a human being an that means hell on earth.

    Posted by Antonio O. | March 5, 2013, 12:51 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Follow Me On Twitter!

%d bloggers like this: