you're reading...
Christianity, Politics

Reflections on Post-9/11 America

I’ve been thinking about what to say about 9/11 for most of a month.  Most of what has come to mind is a list of things I don’t want to talk about.  Yes, the attacks were awful.  Yes, I feel very bad for the people who died and those who lived through it.  Yes, I think the police and fire department were heroes.  Yes to all of that.

But that’s not what I want to reflect upon.  Neither do I want to reflect upon the religious leanings of the hijackers.  Instead, I want to think aloud about the effects American religion has had on Americans since 9/11.

  • I feel sorry for the Catholic families of 9/11 victims who chose to jump out of the buildings rather than burn to death.  How awful must it be for them to grapple with the Catholic doctrine that suicide is an automatic sentence to hell!  Not only do they have to deal with the grief of losing a loved one, but they now have a lifetime of believing that their brothers, fathers, mothers and sisters are suffering the eternal punishment of a God who loved them so much that he sent them to hell for choosing the way they would die.
  • I feel a sinking feeling every time I watch a baseball or football game and have to listen to “God Bless America.”  I reflect on the history of religion insinuating itself into public life in such a dramatic way:  In 1864, in the depths of the Civil War, “In God We Trust” was first added to our currency.  In 1954, “Under God” was added to the pledge of allegiance, as a response to our collective fear of the red menace.  I despair at the exploitation of suffering to blur the lines between state and religion.
  • I feel sorry for those who were brave enough to question the motives of our leaders, and to publicly doubt the veracity of claims about WMD’s.  I can’t imagine what it must have been like forMichael Moore, who was right about the Bush administration’s deceptions, but had to live for years with nine Navy Seals as bodyguards everywhere he went.  I wonder how much of our blind support for Bush the Younger came from his frequent invocations of God’s will.
  • I am saddened that 9/11 has polarized our country to the degree that American Atheists’ attempt to remove blatant religious artifacts from the Memorial Museum elicited hundreds of death threats and thousands of the most hateful comments imaginable.
  • I am appalled that Dominionists — with the exact same political agenda as Islamic extremists in countries like Pakistan — are the leading candidates for the Republican Nomination for the presidency.

If anything, America has been very lucky with regard to terrorist attacks.  The September 11 attacks were dramatic and deeply symbolic, and yes, there was great loss of life.  Nevertheless, in the last 35 years, the total death toll from Islamic terrorists in America is around 3,000.  The odds of being struck by lightning in your life are about 1 in 10,000.  Given the current U.S. population, your odds of being the victim of an Islamic terrorist are 1 in 104,000.

When I think back to 9/11, I realize that the terrorists have won.  That is… if we acknowledge the true identity of those who have successfully terrorized Americans for the past decade.  Paul Wolfowitz, George Bush, Donald Rumsfeld, and the Republican Conservatives who have terrorized us to the point of allowing ourselves to be strip searched anytime we travel by plane — these are the terrorists.  And they have won.  The fact that we still have “Terror Alerts,” and that we are always made aware of the color of our current threat indicator means that the terrorists have won.

We have lived every day since 9/11 in a world where we fear the worst possible thing that could happen, and are willing to give up any freedom to ensure that it is prevented.  Religious leaders have blamed the attacks on gays, on atheists, on liberals.  They have told us that God will protect us if only we turn away from our sin and allow the same kind of theocracy in America that spawned the Islamic extremism in Pakistan and Saudi Arabia.  We have somehow come to believe the lie that if we genuflect before the correct religious icon, have sex with only our heterosexual married spouses, have every baby we conceive, and say grace before meals, that our economy will magically recover, the terrorists will never attack us again, and America will be the greatest nation on earth.

In short, we have almost completely separated our political agendas from the realities of economics.  Ask an average American how to fix the country, and you’re just as likely to hear about morality as job creation.  We have substituted religious ideology for science, empirical data, and the crazy notion of emulating other countries with the kind of employment and income figures we’d like to achieve.  We believe that teaching children about Noah’s Ark and the Garden of Eden will save us.  And all the while, four hundred people grow richer and more powerful by exploiting our collective lunacy.

So today, I am remembering 9/11, but in place of sympathy for several thousand people who suffered greatly a decade ago, I feel utter despair for the 300 million Americans whose lives today are demonstrably less prosperous, less healthy, and more fearful than they were a decade ago.  I fear that we have passed the point of no return, and that the fear mongers — the true terrorists — have convinced us of the lie that the Islamic terrorists were ever the true enemy.

Advertisements

Discussion

15 thoughts on “Reflections on Post-9/11 America

  1. Cross posting fun!

    I’m tired of a lot of things about 9/11.

    I’m tired of stupid conspiracy theories.

    I’m tired of Christians saying everything happens for a reason.

    I’m tired of atheist telling Muslims to get out of America/Europe.

    I’m tired of US foriegn and domestic policy to “make us safer”. including racial/religious profiling and fear mongoring.

    Posted by Alison | September 11, 2011, 6:48 pm
  2. Great post. I’m sure some will say it’s insensitive to the families of those that died, but they can take their mythologies and stick ’em where the sun don’t shine. It’s insensitive for them to tell me I’m going to Hell for being an atheist or agnostic or for harboring beliefs that differ from their own.

    Posted by Harold James Johnson | September 11, 2011, 10:49 pm
  3. Which atheists are telling Muslims to get out of America? I’ll fart in their general direction!

    Posted by Living Life Without a Net | September 11, 2011, 11:12 pm
  4. Over the last decade, atheists have had more opportunities to make progress toward gaining acceptance than we had at any point in the twentieth century. 9/11 not only raises tough questions about the problem of evil, it puts fundamentalists in a difficult spot. If you believe that America has willfully turned away from the true master of the universe, and that this master is an wrathful fellow prone to violently punish disobedience, then you have to, at least on some level, believe that 9/11 was divine punishment. The fact that the attackers themselves claimed to be meting out God’s punishment exposes fundamentalists religious beliefs for what they are–anachronistic, embarrassing, and dangerous.

    Add Bush to the equation, and you’ve got a powerful object lesson in the liabilities of faith. Communism is dead; reactionary antipathy to atheism from that direction, while still real, isn’t nearly as sharp as it was two decades ago. The problems with religion are immediate and blatant. We’re well-positioned to make the case for atheism.

    Yet so many atheists are promoting a culture of scorn and ridicule. “Freethought” is an increasingly ironic label for our movement; in reality, it’s becoming a narrow, dogmatic position which does not even come close to embracing diverse views. Accommodationists are treated with the same ferocity and disdain that Biblical inerrantists show to liberal Christians. It’s almost de rigueur among us now to react to views we disagree with like a MMORPG player whose class just got nerfed. We’re issuing boycotts over comments made in a blog.

    Atheists are not looking very rational these days. We’re not creating a welcoming environment over here. It’s becoming hostile, sophomoric, and frankly, embarrassing.

    Posted by Ian | September 12, 2011, 6:39 am
  5. Ian, I wish there was a “like” button on that comment so I can like it 10 times.

    Posted by Alison | September 12, 2011, 12:58 pm
  6. Thanks! I suppose I should go and post over where the traffic is nowadays…

    Posted by Ian | September 12, 2011, 4:31 pm
  7. Why yes, Ian. I suppose you should. 🙂

    Posted by Living Life Without a Net | September 12, 2011, 6:22 pm
  8. Well, Ian, there is a topic where Hamby asked for opinions on the atheist movement and how to advance it……and then systematically ignored them because they weren’t what he wanted to hear.

    http://freethoughtblogs.com/butterfliesandwheels/2011/09/mor-dialogue-with-william-hamby/

    http://www.examiner.com/atheism-in-atlanta/women-the-atheist-movement

    I think Will is leaning more towards posting more on the examiner as those articles get much more comments than his blog.

    Posted by Alison | September 13, 2011, 12:12 pm
  9. I am new to the atheist activism sphere but I too think we may be going in the wrong direction. We should get the word out but hostility is not the answer.

    On the OP: I think I can honestly say I had a moment of clarity in reading your post. I have not been able to put into words what I feel about 9/11 but you did it for me in a way that moved me to tears.

    Posted by Interested | September 13, 2011, 3:37 pm
  10. I saw the articles on Ophelia’s page. A lot of the comments he got weren’t worth responding to–some of the controversy over elevatorgate is about sexism, but the greater part is the result of people disagreeing with one another in such a way as to escalate conflict rather than resolve it. Which is gonna be an issue in any movement driven by polemics, I suppose.

    Posted by Ian | September 16, 2011, 4:43 pm
  11. Which atheists are telling Muslims to get out of America? I’ll fart in their general direction!

    Well, there are atheists cheering the ban of Muslim praying in public in France and want similar laws in America.

    http://www.rationalresponders.com/forum/30135

    Posted by Alison | September 17, 2011, 4:59 pm
  12. If there is no Free Will, then how can there be “free thought”?

    Posted by CB | September 20, 2011, 9:50 pm
  13. Are you sure I’ve ignored them, Alison? And are you ignoring all the positive comments I got from the women in the atheist movement article? (All of them from… women?)

    Posted by Living Life Without a Net | September 22, 2011, 3:12 pm
  14. Ian, that’s precisely right. And that’s why I’ve been trying to circumvent comment on elevatorgate and try to find anyone who’s interested in talking about how to talk nicely to one another.

    Posted by Living Life Without a Net | September 22, 2011, 3:13 pm
  15. Fine, after re-reading the topic in question, I withdraw my accusation.

    Posted by Alison | September 22, 2011, 5:28 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow Me On Twitter!

%d bloggers like this: